Review by Adam M on January 13, 2026.

This was a great album that was instrumental in the post metal scene as it had a great heaviness and weight to it that was one of a kind.  I used to worship this album constantly, but I presently believe that Panopticon is actually the superior album.  The album is one that is good to get introduced to the band because the songs are enormous and gigantic.  It is also a very atmospheric listen and has a huge impact on you.

The instrumental performances are excellent with cascading guitars and pounding drums and a shouted vocal style that is truly excellent and fits atop the music nicely.  The production is solid and makes the songs come to life.  There is very little to dislike with the way the music is presented as it is both powerful and tuneful at the same time.

The flaw to the work lies in how it is not as experimental and does not reap the rewards in the long run that Panopticon does and this makes it play second fiddle to that work.  There is still an enormous and epic quality to the band that made it one of the best albums of the decade it was released in.  There is simply such character and power to be found.

In conclusion, this is a superb work that is one of the best albums of the style and was revolutionary at the time it was released.  It has the right amount of atmosphere combined with power to create an epic and overwhelming experience.  Those that have not heard the album are highly encouraged to check it out.  There is always something to listen to with this album and it is rightly considered a classic.

Rating: 7.9 out of 10

Review by Allan on October 31, 2002.

After two EP’s Isis released their debut full-length album “Celestial”. “Celestial” was a pivotal move in the Isis sound and was the first big step that Isis made on their journey. “Celestial” and it’s companion EP “Sgnl>05” showed a much more in depth Isis that created a detailed and textured sonic landscape. While “Celestial” was the summation of the Isis sound on their first two EP’s their newest album “Oceanic” is the first step into the future.

Much like the ocean itself in a sense, “Oceanic” demonstrates that it moves through all the various contrasting degrees anywhere between the calm of early morning waves to the violent nature of a midnight storm. It pulls you in and out with its gracefully moving compositions, and then pulls you under during its moments of heartfelt antagonism. Isis successfully brings together the unfathomable size of the ocean depths and the beauty of the ocean and it’s inhabitants together in their music. They’ve constructed a piece of music that makes its way into the subconscious of the listener, reaching a level of realization between itself and its host.

On “Oceanic” Isis has successfully moved beyond the dense barrage of low-end riffing that was fairly prevalent on “Celestial”. They’ve taken their music apart and rebuilt it in a completely new way. They now rely heavily on dynamics, build-ups and breakdowns, minimalism, layering, and texture – somewhat akin to Neurosis but Isis definitely carry their own unique sound. Those elements have always been a part of Isis’ sound, but Isis has never dealt with them to the extent that they have on “Oceanic”.

The music moves along so effortlessly: from mellow moments to sections where you think the outside world is about to collapse on you, to instantaneous segments in which absolute beauty radiates. Even the virtuous female vocals found throughout the album serve as another area where “Oceanic” surprises its listener with further use of dynamics. Also, the vocals of Aaron Turner are so heartfelt and emotionally preformed that they completely push the songs over the edge when they’re used. They’re there to present an atmosphere and everything that comes with that.

Every instrument has its place in Isis’ music. Even non-modal instruments such as the drums serve as a layer that is almost as important as the melody. Keyboards are also present for a large portion of “Oceanic”, putting together an atmospheric undercurrent for the music. Not only that, but there is an acute usage of certain electronic effects which fit the music perfectly. As these songs gradually grow to an immense size and sound through detailing and the layering of the instruments, the songs grow into their climax, and then suddenly they fall apart and build up again in a different way. Yet somehow the theme that they started with still resides in the music. All of this creates a textural scenery and atmosphere for Isis’ music, leaving elements to be discovered again and again after repeated listens.

Bottom Line: “Oceanic” is certainly one of my favorite albums for the year of 2002. It’s amazing to see how much better Isis has gotten since “Celestial”. Don’t get discouraged if “Oceanic” doesn’t immediately click with you. It’s an album that will take time to place its full effect on you, but the reward is far too great to go unnoticed.

Categorical Rating Breakdown

Originality: 9
Musicianship: 10
Atmosphere: 10
Production: 9
Overall: 9

Rating: 9.4 out of 10