Review by Adam M on January 4, 2018.

Allegaeon put a good deal of groove into their songs. There is melody to the band, but certainly a crunchy side as well that makes them varied. I think they sounded fresher at around the time I heard Formshifter, but there is still a very distinctive aura to these tracks. It’s like melodic death metal was given a shot in the arm to craft something even greater and more interesting.

The band is certainly talented and shows their skill on the numerous superb guitar riffs to be found here. The musicianship here is flashy, but not overindulgent by any stretch of the imagination. It makes for a very creative and vital sounding musical performance. The musicianship can be broken down. The guitars have harmony and come together to craft interesting riffs. The vocalist sounds inspired, but nothing special by any stretch of the imagination. Drumming provides the solid backbone for the tracks. One only needs to listen to the first track Proponent for Sentience I – The Conception for an example of the guitars converging towards an interesting purpose. The band still would have the capability of being more original than they are on these songs. It seems they are comfortable with their usual fix of melodic death metal and don’t reach out to craft something more thoughtful. This is the biggest flaw to be found here and only brings the proceedings down slightly.

These songs are still full of life and very enjoyable. The band brims with energy at every pore and it shows through in the songs. This is still not the best of the band and I believe they were onto something more original when Formshifter came out. Those that are fans of melodic death metal with a neat edge to it should find Proponent for Sentience right up their alley, however.

Rating: 7.4 out of 10

Review by Adam M on January 4, 2018.

Allegaeon put a good deal of groove into their songs. There is melody to the band, but certainly a crunchy side as well that makes them varied. I think they sounded fresher at around the time I heard Formshifter, but there is still a very distinctive aura to these tracks. It’s like melodic death metal was given a shot in the arm to craft something even greater and more interesting.

The band is certainly talented and shows their skill on the numerous superb guitar riffs to be found here. The musicianship here is flashy, but not overindulgent by any stretch of the imagination. It makes for a very creative and vital sounding musical performance. The musicianship can be broken down. The guitars have harmony and come together to craft interesting riffs. The vocalist sounds inspired, but nothing special by any stretch of the imagination. Drumming provides the solid backbone for the tracks. One only needs to listen to the first track Proponent for Sentience I – The Conception for an example of the guitars converging towards an interesting purpose. The band still would have the capability of being more original than they are on these songs. It seems they are comfortable with their usual fix of melodic death metal and don’t reach out to craft something more thoughtful. This is the biggest flaw to be found here and only brings the proceedings down slightly.

These songs are still full of life and very enjoyable. The band brims with energy at every pore and it shows through in the songs. This is still not the best of the band and I believe they were onto something more original when Formshifter came out. Those that are fans of melodic death metal with a neat edge to it should find Proponent for Sentience right up their alley, however.

Rating: 7.4 out of 10

Review by Jack on May 15, 2003.

It’s a wonderful thought when you think about how many unearthed bands are out there, plugging away in their garages with nary a decent bit of exposure to the world. Picked up for Rage of Achilles, Omnium Gatherum spring forth with an emphatically energetic shot to the head, possibly not felt as hard since…Soilwork?

“Spirits and August Light” is melodic death through and through. Twin guitar leads, turbulent solos, short catchy atmospheres - the standard formula. However where Omnium Gatherum break away from their legions of contemporaries is in their ability with creative flair and crunchy songwriting. They’re infectious. You feel the need to listen more. I sit down and wonder how 45 minutes have disappeared. What really strikes me about these guys, however, is that instead of following through with the typical half and half clean/harsh vocal mixture, they simply opted to not bother with the clean vocals. It’s metal after all; what the hell do you need to pussy-foot around for? Not a clean line to be had. And you know what? It kills.

I didn’t have to skip through one track when listening to “Spirits and August Light.” You can literally pick out any of the nine songs on this debut record and be warmly greeted with a lush, melodic soundscape.

There is a peculiar quality about Omnium Gatherum. Soilwork have it, In Flames have it, Dark Tranquillity have it, and what is more important, “Spirits and August Light” certainly has it.

Bottom Line: “Hatebreeder”? You loved it? Grab “Spirits and August Light.” Dark Tranquillity? You love them, too? Omnium Gatherum could be one of your new favorite acts. The field of melodic death metal is without a doubt one of the hardest metal scenes to open the door to. Omnium Gatherum have simply bypassed the security and waltzed in. Screw the trials and tribulations 99% of bands face. Meet the new face of melodic death metal.

Categorical Rating Breakdown

Musicianship: 9
Atmosphere: 9
Production: 8.5
Originality: 8
Overall: 9.5

Rating: 8.8 out of 10