Review by Adam M on November 10, 2010.

Interesting emotionally driven Rock that has some metallic tendencies is delivered by Lis Er Stille. There is an emphasis on the textures created by the guitar. Also, expect other elements like the use of piano to give this a more well-rounded feeling that encompasses all different sorts of music. This is demonstrated by the third track 'Recalling The Color' which features exciting instrumental portions, but no vocals for much of its running time. The vocals are regardless quite strong throughout the remainder of the work.

The progressive melange is well done and makes the band sound energetic and full of life at some occasions and appropriately mellow and chilling at others. There is certainly an experimental standpoint to the disc as seen from its long running length alone. The open ended nature of the album is one that is going to cause divided opinion on the quality of what’s to be found, but I find the material here to be compelling. When Lis Er Stille is on form, the music is haunting and pulls the listener into the mix. The music of Jeff Buckley is an appropriate comparison point in terms of the dramatic atmosphere created, although this band appears to be even more chaotic. There is certainly an emotional rock vibe created here though and though it has some metal tendencies, it’s often more oriented towards rock.

Lis Er Stille has subtlety, but could have more of the metallic intensity that you’ll find from greats in the genre. The album is one that is definitely progressive, regardless of whether it is rock or metal to and fulfills in creating an enthralling listen. Sure, it’s has moments when it drags a bit, but I think Lis Er Stille have succeeded in creating a work that flows nicely for the most part. The Collibro comes recommended to fans of music in general that have an open mind to appreciate an ambitious listen.

Categorical Rating Breakdown

Musicianship: 9
Atmosphere: 9
Production: 8.5
Originality: 8
Overall: 8.5

Rating: 8.6 out of 10

Review by JD on November 22, 2013.

When I think what there all is about France, I have to admit the thought of Heavy Metal does not instantly leap into my mind. I think of well-aged wines and cheeses, refined food and a long history when I think of France, not any types of metal. I have heard only a handful of bands from France. With this review, it will show that perhaps we need to look into the country’s metal scene a little harder.

Surtr comes from the Northeast of France, and brings a tight and powerful Traditional Doom Metal style packed and polished with its own sort of twists and turns to the world. Consisting of only three members, Surtr still bring forth a very explosive sound. Named after the Norse Mythology Giant, Surtr’s music seems to be as large and powerful as the Viking legend itself.

With all of the subtly of a Tiger tank on low gear speed, these three French Metallers pull no punches and give a Classic Doom Metal performance. One listen to either 'Rise Again' or the glacier-slow speed power of 'Sonic Doom', it is clear that this trio is one impressive-albeit slow and brooding, powerhouse that is hard to ignore.

Comparing this French band with some of the Doom Metal’s highest elite like the mighty Candlemass or even older My Dying Bride– Surtr is one of a handful of bands out there that will get into that inner Doom circle. With this type of excellence, I am sure that even the non doomers out there will be very pleased if they picked up "Pulvis Et Umbra" for their collections.

Categorical Rating Breakdown

Musicianship: 9
Atmosphere: 9.5
Production: 8.5
Originality: 9
Overall: 9

Rating: 9 out of 10

Review by JD on November 22, 2013.

When I think what there all is about France, I have to admit the thought of Heavy Metal does not instantly leap into my mind. I think of well-aged wines and cheeses, refined food and a long history when I think of France, not any types of metal. I have heard only a handful of bands from France. With this review, it will show that perhaps we need to look into the country’s metal scene a little harder.

Surtr comes from the Northeast of France, and brings a tight and powerful Traditional Doom Metal style packed and polished with its own sort of twists and turns to the world. Consisting of only three members, Surtr still bring forth a very explosive sound. Named after the Norse Mythology Giant, Surtr’s music seems to be as large and powerful as the Viking legend itself.

With all of the subtly of a Tiger tank on low gear speed, these three French Metallers pull no punches and give a Classic Doom Metal performance. One listen to either 'Rise Again' or the glacier-slow speed power of 'Sonic Doom', it is clear that this trio is one impressive-albeit slow and brooding, powerhouse that is hard to ignore.

Comparing this French band with some of the Doom Metal’s highest elite like the mighty Candlemass or even older My Dying Bride– Surtr is one of a handful of bands out there that will get into that inner Doom circle. With this type of excellence, I am sure that even the non doomers out there will be very pleased if they picked up "Pulvis Et Umbra" for their collections.

Categorical Rating Breakdown

Musicianship: 9
Atmosphere: 9.5
Production: 8.5
Originality: 9
Overall: 9

Rating: 9 out of 10