Estertor - Official Website
Evil Black Church |
Spain
![]() |
|---|
Review by Dominik on November 16, 2026.
For those of you who are first exposed to Estertor's craft, don't let yourself misled by the song titles and visual aesthetics. What initially smells like a dose of blackened death or thrash metal, turns out to be the latter in a rather pure form. The Spanish dudes rely on the well-known ingredients of the genre, with one major deviation from its unwritten laws: the band's frontman, who is everything but your typical snarling and angry thrash metal vocalist. His performance borders on theatricality, and you never quite know whether he wants to personify an evil preacher reciting his sermons from the pulpit, or simply experiments how it would sound if Mayhem's Attila Csihar decided to go thrash. The result at times feels like a half-baked opera parody, but one thing can be said for sure: he gives the album a distinctive character, what helps to make it stay well above your average genre release.
"Evil Black Church" starts strong, perhaps a little too strong for my taste, as most of what follows the short instrumental interlude "March Of The Dèmoni" struggles to maintain the outstanding quality of the opening trio. The title track kicks off the riff massacre, and I was relieved to find that the band has stuck to the approach of its very good predecessor. The pace is high, and the unmistakable vocalist, backed by fast drumming and hard-hitting riffs, drives the song toward a chorus that practically begs you to sing along. Before you know it, tolling bells interrupt the proceedings halfway through, making way for some solo madness. Nothing particularly revolutionary here, but this is textbook thrash of the bestseller variety rather than some dusty document forgotten in the cellar of your local library.
Before you've even finished shouting "Gimme more of that!", "Night Of The Owl" picks up where the opener left off. Perhaps even a tad better than the opener, this is yet another solid banger which demonstrates that thrash works best when it doesn't get too technical but instead aims for maximum impact. I have to admit, though, that again there's nothing here you haven't heard before, but everything is performed with absolute conviction. Estertor shows a knack for simple yet captivating riffs and solos. Also the production manages to convince by successfully combining modern technology with the genre's old-school roots. The imploring vocals further elevate the song, and even after countless listens, I couldn't identify a single moment when they felt completely out of place. There is one unfortunate exception, though, but let's not bury the body just yet.
"Scumbags From Hell" reveals two more facets of Estertor. First, they aren't afraid to throw in some speed metal and punk influences. Second, their frontman proves that his vocal range extends well beyond what we've heard so far. Driven largely by double-bass drumming, the song boasts a catchy chorus and rightfully earns its place on the podium alongside the album's two opening highlights. The aforementioned "March Of The Dèmoni" is where some of the little marching troublemakers apparently decide to wreak some havoc on the remaining songs. With the exception of "Nightmare Returns", Estertor gradually starts shaving off some of the album's initial greatness.
"Open Coffin Empty Grave" suffers from a somewhat generic chorus. The band skillfully plays around with different tempos, but I stand by my opinion that the song deserved a much better one. Don't get me wrong, this isn't some dramatic nosedive into mediocrity, but after such an excellent opening, it leaves a rather unpleasant smell of wasted potential. Unfortunately, this impression is reinforced by the closing track, "Seven Portals Of Evil". Conceptually and in terms of emotional impact, it reminds me of Cruel Force's title track "Haneda" from their latest album. In both cases, the bands seem to sabotage an otherwise promising idea or two that could have filled a four-minute banger to the brim by stretching it well beyond eight minutes. The song starts promisingly enough, with a nice alternation between faster and mid-tempo passages, but halfway through, it gradually loses steam and direction. What follows is a rather aimless wander through musical territory that doesn't always seem to know where it wants to go. Estertor then throws in pretty much everything we haven't heard elsewhere on the album: some acoustic shrubbery, traditional heavy metal elements, more melodic solos and a vocalist who suddenly decides to try his hand at actual singing. Unfortunately, this last experiment doesn't exactly qualify him for a second career in musical theater. None of these ingredients is particularly bad in isolation, but most feel misplaced and do little to improve the overall picture. The fact that the song regains some of its initial energy toward the end feels more like an alibi than a genuine attempt to salvage what has already been lost. Even the seven portals of evil apparently have their limits.
Despite the unfortunate decision to bring "Evil Black Church" to a rather limp conclusion, I can still wholeheartedly recommend this album to any thrash fanatic who prefers the old ways to the overhyped modern variety served up by bands such as Struck A Nerve and their ilk. Estertor delivers a convincing dose of old-school thrash, equipped with enough personality to stand out from the crowd. Just don't expect all seven portals to lead to musical salvation.
Rating: 8.3 out of 10, because even with a few demons running amok in the second half, Estertor still delivers enough old-school firepower to keep the church bells ringing. Amen, and pass the earplugs.
130
